Ask for the Introduction: Turning Relationships Into Opportunities with Phil “The Connector” Herrington

EPISODE: 68


Phil “The Connector” Herrington spent more than three decades in sales, including years of cold calling and door-to-door prospecting. When he discovered business networking, he brought that same sales mindset with him—and admits he initially got it completely wrong. He treated every one-to-one like a lead instead of a relationship.

Today, Phil helps B2B business owners build strategic relationships through The Connector Community. In this episode, we talk about what changed when he stopped trying to close every conversation and started focusing on giving first. We also get practical about the other side of relationship-first sales: eventually, you still have to ask. Phil shares how to make that ask easier, why he prefers introductions over referrals, and how consistency and enough conversations keep a pipeline moving without turning people into numbers. phil-tam-take-02

In this episode, we talk about:

  • Why your first networking conversation doesn’t need to become a sales call

  • The simple shift from asking for “referrals” to asking for specific introductions

  • How to create value before asking someone to buy

  • Why relationship-first sellers still need to get comfortable making the ask

  • How consistent prospecting keeps you out of the feast-or-famine cycle


LISTEN TO THE EPISODE HERE 👇🏻


MORE OF A READER? 👇🏻

There’s a tension I see all the time in sales.

On one side are people who have been taught to treat every conversation like an opportunity to close. On the other are business owners who care deeply about relationships and are so determined not to be “salesy” that they never actually ask for anything.

Neither extreme works particularly well.

My conversation with Phil “The Connector” Herrington was interesting because he has lived both sides.

Phil spent more than 30 years in sales, including cold calling and door-to-door prospecting. When he eventually discovered business networking, he approached those conversations the way he had been trained to approach sales: everyone was a lead.

After thousands of one-to-one conversations, his approach changed.

Instead of going into every meeting wondering, How do I turn this person into a customer?, he started asking questions. Who are they? Who do they serve? What are they trying to accomplish? And most importantly: How can I help?

That doesn’t mean there’s no place for selling.

It means we stop trying to make every conversation do everything.

One of Phil’s recommendations is to separate the initial relationship-building conversation from the sales conversation.

That first meeting can simply be about getting to know someone.

Ask questions. Listen. Look for ways to add value. Phil’s goal is to get to the point where the other person naturally asks, “So, what do you do?”

And if there’s genuine interest? Book another conversation.

The person sitting across from you may not need your service today. They may never need it. But they may become a referral partner, collaborator, resource, or someone who introduces you to exactly the person you need to know.

If we decide someone has no value because they aren’t buying from us, we miss most of what a network can actually do.

One of my favorite practical ideas from our conversation was Phil’s approach to referrals.

He asks for introductions.

And he gets specific.

“Do you know anyone who could use my services?” puts a lot of work on the other person. Their brain has to figure out who you serve, who might need you, and who would be comfortable receiving an introduction.

Compare that with asking whether they know a COO, an accounting firm, a staffing company, or whatever specific person fits your audience.

Now there’s something concrete to respond to.

As Phil put it, ask for anybody and you often get nobody.

This may have been the most important part of our conversation.

Those of us who believe deeply in relationship-first sales can sometimes overcorrect. We don’t want to pressure anyone, so we keep giving, nurturing and building relationships—but never actually make the ask.

At some point, you have to.

Ask for the introduction. Ask for the next conversation. Ask if they want to explore working together.

The difference is that the ask comes from a relationship and a genuine understanding of what the other person needs.

I used to resist the idea that sales is a numbers game because it sounded transactional.

But Phil offered a framing I can get behind: a numbers game with heart.

You can care deeply about people and still know your numbers.

If you know how many conversations typically lead to opportunities and how many opportunities become clients, you don't have to put the weight of your entire revenue goal on the person sitting in front of you.

You can simply have the conversation.

That’s where consistency matters. Phil pointed out that one of the easiest ways to create feast or famine is to stop prospecting as soon as business gets busy. Then the work slows down, the pipeline is empty, and you have to start rebuilding again.

Relationship-first sales isn't passive.

It’s a consistent practice of meeting people, listening, giving, asking and staying connected.

And sometimes, growing your business really can begin with one thoughtful introduction.


✦ YOUR SALES AS SERVICE CHALLENGE

This week, pick one person already in your network—a client, former client, partner, colleague, or someone you’ve built a genuine relationship with.

Instead of asking, “Do you know anyone who needs what I do?” make the ask specific.

Think about the kind of person or business you want to meet, then ask: “Who comes to mind when you think of [specific role, industry, or type of business]?”

If someone comes to mind, ask whether they’d be comfortable making an introduction.

Then return the favor. Ask who they would like to meet and look for one connection, resource, or opportunity you can share.

Relationship-first selling doesn’t mean never asking. It means earning the right to ask—and making it easy for someone to help.


RESOURCES & LINKS


GET THE CLIENT PIPELINE CALCULATOR

If this episode got you thinking about your own pipeline, the Client Pipeline Calculator shows you how many conversations stand between you and your next client. Get the calculator →

And if you loved this episode, subscribe and leave a review on Apple Podcasts — it helps more service pros find the show.


TAM SMITH

I’m Tam Smith-Sales Growth Strategist and Founder of Studio Three 49. I help service-based founders find, connect with, and convert right-fit clients through predictable, sustainable outbound sales solutions.

No pushy pitches. No bro-marketing. Just simple, structured systems that turn connections into clients.


Previous
Previous

The Cost of Being Busy: What Founders Get Wrong About Business Growth with Nicole Meloni

Next
Next

Where Good Leads Get Stuck: Why They Aren’t Becoming Clients with Brian Ondrako